Soft Alpaca wrote: Thu Jun 16, 2022 8:24 am
I'm not saying that I can't see the difference between the two however when looking at Capricorn we use Autonomy, Uranus we use independence , Pluto we use social outlier. I am equally all three but I feel like we as a community could do a better job in separating these close meanings just a bit further, and many people likely blend the three including myself.
I agree with you completely.
Now, I'm not worried that some words apply interchangeably with more than one astrological factor - that the obviously martial words "energy" and "strength" can apply equally to Sun (and, especially, to Moon-Sun aspects), or that "survival" is as suitable to Mars as Saturn. Still, these come from different motives, different specifics. Mercury is as
active of Mars but it's a different kind of activity. Moon and Venus are equally tender, Moon and Neptune similarly vulnerable.
But we can certainly fine-tune this in a way that reflects underlying needs and motives better. Lately I've been using "independence" more for Saturn because it specifically contrasts Saturn to the opposing lunar idea of dependence. Saturn and Uranus are a great study in this, probably something that should be a standard training question for astrology student, because so many words apply
exactly as well to one as to the other - even though their underlying natures of restriction vs. freedom are essentially opposite. (How does this happen? Probably because the
combination and interplay of freedom and restriction is necessary for real independence, or something like that.)
I touched on these distinctions above (and it took me a day to realize that your answer came in
after I did that, not just before. Of all the kinds of independence, Saturn (the survival need) is mostly, "I'm going to live my life my own damn way, stop interfering!" Uranus (the freedom and renewal needs, the same thing that will have an animal chew off a leg to get out of a trap) is "there is SO MUCH SPACE," meaning physical and metaphysical and conceptual and intellectual and emotional space. Freedom to Saturn is making its own survival decisions (with quite a willingness to be bound or attached, often using definition and boundary to accomplish this); to Uranus, it is a feeling of being
unbounded with new things to experience everywhere, the surging feeling of our nervous system adapting to previously undetected things.
In contrast, Pluto is just, "leave me alone," the real motive being to be what one inherently is without other people trying to say it should be different or {bonk} with it somehow. It's the
authenticity need. Whereas Moon is our natural adaptation to our physical, psychological, and social environment, Pluto is revulsed by the idea that it should have to adapt itself to those environments. (It's not averse to physical adaptation, but revulsed at being expected to adapt to social or psychological expectations.)