I think not, considering that there are hard published statistics on lunar returns showing childbirths, weddings, and violent accidents.Arena wrote: Mon Dec 30, 2024 10:39 am I'm just wondering if the lunars are more about our inner feelings and reactions to what's happening around us, rather than outside events. There are so many lunars in here that have the potential to be "outstanding" but they are not bringing about any unusual or outstanding events and that may be because the solar return is not indicating "outstanding" circumstances or events from the outside environment.
I think the lunar component isn't so much feelings as responsiveness to conditions (thin difference, I know). For the most part, I think lunar returns focus and filter the relative importance of transits and are essentially transit charts. I think them no more subjective than the other things you mention.
By current SLR with Sun-Jupiter square closely foreground brought in more money in one week than I'm used to getting in, say, four typical months. This was something I'd been planning for, maneuvering toward, etc., but the currents came together at exactly that spot to make it all happen. If I merely felt good because I got my predictable December bonus and the holidays were coming, that would be equally Sun-Jupiter but really not worthy of the best SLR I'm having for the next year.