Page 1 of 1
Playing God (Millard example)
Posted: Thu May 25, 2023 10:56 am
by Jim Eshelman
Gayle, July 14, 1958, 10:32 PM, Portland, ME
(The chart she published says 1968 but is clearly calculated for 1958.)
Dr. Millard wrote:It was with great pity and a sense of guilt that I studied the record: "The woman was an obese eighteen year old, dull looking but seeming to understand. She was in a wheelchair. The chief complaint is of fecal incontinence secondary to her long previous history of paraplegia. She enters hospital to have a colostomy."
Gayle was born with a meningomyelocele. The lower end of the spinal cord, from which arise the nerves supplying the bladder, bowel, and legs, was exposed in a sack, and covered only with a thin layer of skin. (Neural tube defects can now be diagnosed in pregnancy by a blood test on the mother, and by a test of the amniotic fluid.)
In the old days, the sac always began to leak spinal fluid and became infected. Then the child died of meningitis.
About twenty years ago, surgery had become sufficiently advanced to be able to operate on these children. The nerves in the sac can be freed and covered with skin. The children then lived, because they did not become infected, and even the most 'successful' cases developed hydrocephalus and mental retardation.
When Gayle was born, this complication was well recognized, and to prevent it, a shunt was constructed to take away excess fluid from the ventricles of the brain. In her case, the left kidney was removed and the shunt placed in the left ureter.
The technique has improved, and now it is placed in the atrium of the heart. The excess fluid passes into the circulation... However, Gayle was born before this method was introduced. Her developing hydrocephalus was arrested, and though a "slow learner," she definitely was not retarded. She seemed a normal nine year old, although desperately ill when she entered hospital with E. coli meningitis, which had then reached the brain from a urinary tract infection on November 17, 1967.
It seemed that she would probably die. Meningitis alone is a potentially fatal disease, but meningitis in the presence of a brain to ureter shunt is impossible cure without removing the shunt, which acts as a foreign body. Antibiotic treatment began at once, but despite this, the pressure in the brain was very great and kept increasing. The blood pressure rose with it, in order to maintain the flow of blood through the brain. It reached the incredible height of 300/200, and we had called in a neurosurgeon to put a pressure monitor in her skull when she suddenly herniated her brainstem through the foramen magnum and sank into a very deep coma. She was totally paralyzed, both arms and legs, and death seemed but hours away.
It was the weekend. I was on duty and sat with her. She was bleeding into her stomach and into her skin, lungs, and b rain. Unless the blood pressure could be reduced, she would bleed to death. I started [various drugs] but none brought it down. As a last resort, I put up an Arfonad drip... to dilate the blood vessels which were in spasm and keeping her pressure as high. She was insensitive to it, but I sat with her through the night and monitored her. Little by little the bleeding ceased and so she lived.
I never thought she would be paralyzed. Her arms gradually returned to normal, but her legs never moved again.
After her blood pressure and intracranial pressure had stabilized, and her kidney function, which temporarily had ceased, returned, she was taken to the operating room and the shunt was removed. The meningitis slowly cleared.
I do not know how much her brain was damaged, and whether it was due to the meningitis or the high pressure. She seemed much more retarded after her illness. Her family could not cope with looking after her in a wheelchair, and she was sent to an institution for retarded children where she remained for several years.
The legs used to go into intolerably painful muscle spasms. As cordotomy was done... to cut the nerves in the spinal cord. She was incontinent of urine, so her bladder was removed and her ureters diverted into the bowel. Then she was incontinent of faeces, so a colostomy was carried out in April 1977.
She had a nervous breakdown and was in the psych ward in the summer of 1976. She must have insight int her condition, for people who are very retarded to not have acute psychotic episodes.
I have seen her once since then. She was in a wheelchair, and she did not remember her illness. Since then, she has seen more doctors than one can count, and her treatment must have run into thousands of [1970s] dollars. Worse than that is the thought as to the kind of future she has to look forward to.
Re: Playing God (Millard example)
Posted: Thu May 25, 2023 12:27 pm
by Jim Eshelman
My analysis: There is SO MUCH going on here and, regrettably, I've had to copy nearly the entire chapter just to get the medical details. The printed birth data was 10 years in error (which was interesting because the chart for that data made no sense) but, once I got the right chart, it made a lot more sense.
The nativity, at the briefest glance, shows a chart of someone living a pretty miserable, hard life with a lot of hurt. I'll let you set it up yourself for full effect (and don't forget the mundoscope). Even the partile Sun-Jupiter square doesn't give much relief in the face of all the rest. (It probably refers to a life being care-taken and receiving constant medical oversight and treatment.)
To begin the medical analysis, let's first breakdown her condition into discrete problems:
- Born with a meningomyelocele (lower end of spinal cord exposed in a sack, covered only with a thin layer of skin).
- Surgical intervention covered the exposed nerves with skin, then, to avoid deadly consequences, constructed a shunt to drain excess fluid from the brain. For this, one kidney was removed and the shunt placed in the freed ureter.
- Reduced mental capacity, but not severe initially. (It worsened after the major crises described.)
- At age 9, a urinary tract infection reached the brain. She became "desperately ill." During this, there were severe secondary effects including extremely high blood pressure causing profuse internal bleeding everywhere and herniated the brain stem, producing "very deep coma" and total paralysis.
- Treatment resolved the meningitis and resolved the immediate crisis.
- Intercranial pressure and blood pressure shut down her kidneys temporarily, but this returned. later. Coming out of this, she regained upper extremity mobility but not her legs. Some further brain damage resulted. Later surgeries resulted in bladder removal (thus u8rinary incontinence), bowel incontinence (thus a colostomy), and a later nervous breakdown while institutionalized. Constrained to a wheel chair.
Based on my current approach, here are the primary medical astrology considerations:
- Sun is remotely background but well-aspected with a partile square to Jupiter; therefore vitality isn't great, but has extra protection (e.g., good heart health, many functions working very well),
- Moon in Gemini refers to the legs (and theoretically to the nerves: both lights are in Gemini).
- Mars in Aries is primarily connected to the kidneys-bladder, uterus, buttocks-bowel.
- Acutely foreground Venus-Saturn opposition (Taurus-Scorpio) dominates the chart and has its usual meanings. I could see this spilling over into explicit health matters just because it dominates everything, but it seems it did not - an important observation. None of the typical Venus-Saturn health concerns resulted despite the huge set of system breakdowns.
- No background hard aspects, but quite a few middleground mundane aspects exist, more important because they involve Moon and Mars which are always important for illness.
- Mundanely, Mars opposes a Jupiter-Neptune conjunction, all square Moon. The oppositions occur across Libra-Aries, with Moon in Gemini. Also, a moderate Mercury-Uranus conjunction (mundo).
The big concerns, then, are in Gemini and Aries parts of the body, and the Moon-Mars-Neptune (+ some Jupiter) mundane T-square and maybe the Mercury-Uranus conjunction. These are the main things we have to work with, and they do a really good job of describing the weakest and most afflicted body parts and functions (including most of the secondary and tertiary effects).
Re: Playing God (Millard example)
Posted: Thu May 25, 2023 1:26 pm
by Jim Eshelman
Jim Eshelman wrote: Thu May 25, 2023 12:27 pm
The big concerns, then, are in Gemini and Aries parts of the body, and the Moon-Mars-Neptune (+ some Jupiter) mundane T-square and maybe the Mercury-Uranus conjunction. These are the main things we have to work with, and they do a really good job of describing the weakest and most afflicted body parts and functions (including most of the secondary and tertiary effects).
The least evident to me, though, is the original problem from birth, from which all the others extended: Gayle was born with a meningomyelocele, the most threatening form of spinal bifida in which the lower end of her spinal cord is exposed. I think we see this at birth only in the overall hardness of the chart, such as Saturn exactly at MC and the Venus-Saturn opposition. It's a congenital problem (several of those have Venus-Saturn common) and seems primarily a
bone issue. There are no afflictions (and barely any placements) in the signs connected to the spine specifically, so the "spinal deformity" theme of the dominant Venus-Saturn aspect seems the best indication.
Her chart is better at showing what happened next - after she was born. There is a philosophical and practical question of how much we can expect a horoscope to show conditions already existing
before birth - I just throw this question out there for consideration.
However, once this problem existed, the chart caught every major piece of what happened next:
Mars opposite Neptune, Aries to Libra: Aries corresponds to the kidneys-urethra-bladder, the uterus-ovaries, and the buttocks-rectum-bowel. By reflex action, it might affect the head region, though we don't need that excuse in this case because we have the Mars-Neptune opposition across Aries-Libra.
This is pretty amazing: Gayle's first surgery as an infant was a surgical removal of one kidney to build a shunt between the freed ureter and her brain - a direct physical bridge between the two body parts on the Aries-Libra axis. Nine years later, an
infection (Mars-Neptune) spread across this direct Aries-to-Libra (ureter-to-brain) line to cause all the other cascading problems.
All the effects listed thereafter came from this one line. However, most of them expressed through body parts shown by her chart to be weakened or vulnerable. Heightened blood pressure and consequent everywhere-bleeding is something listed for Moon-Mars.
Notice that her remaining kidney temporarily shut down during the crisis described above. She also later lost control of bladder and bowel following surgery and cascading problems over time (Mars in Aries).
The neurological aspects are least obvious but have two likely correspondences. First, she has an afflicted Gemini Moon and, besides corresponding to the legs, Gemini seems to show vulnerability to the nerves overall. I'm also inclined to credit the 3°31'M Mercury-Uranus conjunction, associated with electrical processes in the brain and nerves, nervous disorder, matters concerning spinal neural channels, etc.
With her Moon sign corresponding to the legs, her eventual loss of the use of legs is described. (Moon squares Mars-Neptune closely: Damage to legs from health concerns tied into the Mars-Neptune opposition.)
A few details to complete the picture:
- Moon-Mars: Bleeding, fever, inflammation, infection, dehydration. Tissue engorgement.
- Moon-Neptune: Fluid disturbances. Blood impurities. Edema.
- Mars-Jupiter: Healthy muscular system, energy, strength. Other problems expected that didn't appear or were not reported here.
- Mars-Neptune: Illness in general. Toxic or infectious agents; increased sensitivity to chemicals, allergens, foods, or infection. Muscular atrophy, weakness, paralysis. Painful edema.
Re: Playing God (Millard example)
Posted: Thu May 25, 2023 1:42 pm
by Jim Eshelman
Dr. Millard wrote:
...desperately ill when she entered hospital with E. coli meningitis, which had then reached the brain from a urinary tract infection on November 17, 1967.
Solar Arc directions singling out this stage of her life as when a crisis might hit:
26°08' Sco - r Saturn
26°45' Aqu - d Asc
26°49' Sco - r MC
27°19' Tau - r Venus
By secondary progressions, her natal Aries-Libra infection potential also became ripe, probably setting off the whole pattern:
6°52' Can - p Sun
7°49' Ari - p Mars
7°51' Lib - r Neptune
Transiting Pluto was still in partile orb of square her Venus, but out of partile orb to other factors. Otherwise, transits were pretty boring. But her solunars were anything but boring! This all started with a urinary tract infection that spread and her October 23 SLR had:
6°25' Sag - t Mars
7°05' Gem - r Moon
8°26' Gem - SLR Asc
Her SSR had already set up the year as rough:
17°19' Pis - SSR MC
18°06' Pis - t Saturn
19°04' Gem - t Mercury
3°37' Lib - t Mars
4°56' Can - SSR Asc
7°50' Lib - t Moon
7°51' Lib - r Neptune
Her SLR was equally on target, though the Demi seemed mismatched, perhaps only showing the medical intervention.
Re: Playing God (Millard example)
Posted: Fri May 26, 2023 6:32 am
by SteveS
Jim wrote:
By secondary progressions, her natal Aries-Libra infection potential also became ripe, probably setting off the whole pattern:
6°52' Can - p Sun
7°49' Ari - p Mars
7°51' Lib - r Neptune
Footnote on page 210 of Ebertin’s “The Combinations of Stellar Influences”:
Mars-Neptune contacts should be given particular considerations in cases of illness as it often characteristic of an infection from outside or a type of auto-toxin which in severe cases can lead to death if the body has not been freed of the toxin early on.
Re: Playing God (Millard example)
Posted: Fri May 26, 2023 10:14 am
by Jim Eshelman
Yes, that's exactly what was going on, though in this case it was an infection instead of a toxin.
In this case, what really impressed me were (1) that the natal pattern was clearly there PROVIDED you look at the mundane aspects also, and (2) the signs of the natal configuration were so precise in providing details (locations in the body).
Re: Playing God (Millard example)
Posted: Sun May 28, 2023 5:05 am
by SteveS
Yes, I understand with the mundane aspects, but I am not that experience with medical astrology by only looking at the Sun & Moon Signs. I do understand the lights showing malific aspects is a red flag for potential life health problems.
Re: Playing God (Millard example)
Posted: Sun May 28, 2023 7:22 am
by Jim Eshelman
Steve, I have a thread above about the overall procedure. The main factors to look for vulnerability - where thr body is likely to manifest a health issue if that's how it's expressing - is this:
1. Moon sign shows where in the body one is most vulnerable to disease or hurt.
2. Mars sign shows where one is most likely to get hurt, especially in Mars ways (inflammation, cutting, accident, etc.).
3. Close hard aspects that are NOT Foreground (especially if deeply background) show powerful energies and needs that are not likely to find expression in life. Since they Must express somehow, they often do so as health failures. More often than not, their signs will be relevant to the body location (like the link between the kidneys and brain in this Aries to Libra aspect).
Re: Playing God (Millard example)
Posted: Sun May 28, 2023 7:26 am
by SteveS
Excellent Jim, thanks, I have copied and pasted to a word document of important observations by you.
Re: Playing God (Millard example)
Posted: Sun May 28, 2023 7:54 am
by Jim Eshelman
I meant to add an earlier step above:
0. Sun shows overall vitality. A person with low vitality (little life force) will respond differently than a person with high, strong vitality (much access to life force). Sun shows this by angularity and Moon aspect. Foreground Sun shows unusually high vitality. middleground shows average vitality, and background shows lower vitality than average (unless boosted by a Moon aspect).
Steve, here is the thread that sorted these out. I'll updated after I write the medical astrology chapter in the near future.
viewtopic.php?f=73&t=4845
Here is a collection of planet and aspect significances for medical astrology. I've already rewritten in somewhat (in the chapter, not on the forum) to flesh out the aspects a little better, but this is still essentially what I'd say:
viewtopic.php?f=73&t=3370
Here is an older thread where I was first working these through and used my own chart as an example:
viewtopic.php?f=73&t=1796
Re: Playing God (Millard example)
Posted: Mon May 29, 2023 1:37 pm
by Venus_Daily
Great examples, Jim. I'm wondering if Venus in Vrgo receiving a mundane aspect from my Moon signifies my vulnurable pituitary gland. I've always been extremely sensitive emotionally, but as an adult, it became even worse, which is probably due to extreme hormonal fluctuations and having to take hormones in an artificial way that can never really mimic the pituitary. I know that my foreground Mars makes me really expressive and gives me a bad poker face, so people always know what I'm feeling, but I have always been subject to extreme emotions that can be described as "hormonal".
Re: Playing God (Millard example)
Posted: Tue May 30, 2023 7:27 am
by Jim Eshelman
My guess is that you are right. I would expect the potential for any kind of hormonal aspect from Moon-Venus, especially things that are colloquially (but not always kindly) called "being hormonal."
Re: Playing God (Millard example)
Posted: Tue May 30, 2023 12:59 pm
by Venus_Daily
It's odd how before I got into Sideral astrology, I always knew I had a heavy Venusian/Lunar influence, but it wasn't until I became more familiar with mundane aspects that it was really explained. Venus in Virgo is really spot on for hypoproduction of natural hormones and Youthfulness/neoteny. I'm 38 but everyone always assumes I'm in my mid 20s.
Re: Playing God (Millard example)
Posted: Tue May 30, 2023 1:04 pm
by Jim Eshelman
Venus_Daily wrote: Tue May 30, 2023 12:59 pm
It's odd how before I got into Sideral astrology, I always knew I had a heavy Venusian/Lunar influence, but it wasn't until I became more familiar with mundane aspects that it was really explained.
For Moon-Venus aspects (like your background mundane square), I have suggested the following medical correlations: Hormones in general. Biological femininity: Female reproduction, menstruation, all fluids related to female reproduction. Interaction of hindbrain and limbic system.
You also have that close Venus-Jupiter square. Jupiter is middleground and it maty be that you express these energies in other ways, but, if they have a health expression I would expect the following correlations: Hormones related to digestion and nutrition. Pancreas, liver-kidney interaction (glucose synthesis). Healthy female reproductive system and hormone metabolism. Relaxation, body homeostasis (parasympathetic responses). Sense of well-being, consequences of indulgence. (? Tin toxicity.)